Top 10 Idol Contestants - "Glad You Came" B This was supremely cheesy, of course it was, but somehow it was cheesy in a good way. I loved their coordinated white outfits and it actually looked like the Idol contestants were having a good time (not always the case with these choreographed, often lipsynced group numbers).
The Band Perry & Janelle Arthur - "Done" A+ UNBELIEVABLY fun to watch. This was a country music tribute to hair metal and I loved every minute of it. The choreographed kicks, headbanging, fire, and those haircuts. Wow, this was just amazing. THIS was the perfect example of a duet/group performance where the band actually looks like they are interacting with the Idol contestant. It even seemed like Janelle was in their band which is the highest possible compliment I could give. It's a shame the producers didn't really let any of the contestants do uptempo songs this year, as its evident they could have kicked ass at them.
Top 5 Guys & Frankie Valli - Four Seasons Medley/"Can't Take My Eyes Off Of You"/"Grease" A
This had me up off my seat rocking out, no surprise! I love Motown and the music of the 60's. This was cheesy, safe fun.
Mariah Carey - "Vision Of Love"/"Make It Happen"/"My All"/"Hero"/"We Belong Together"/"#Beautiful" B
As you can see, Mariah performed no less than 6 songs in this performance. While I LOVE Mariah's music and a greatest hits medley sounds amazing, the short clips didn't give any song any time to build and reach its full peak or potential. It would have been awesome to start with We Belong Together and segue into her new hit #Beautiful. I love Mariah but there was just way too much going on here.
Amber Holcomb & Emilie Sande - "Next To Me" B-
The vibe between Amber and Emilie was a bit awkward, as if they hadn't rehearsed or didn't really know how to react to each other. Especially compared to Janelle singing with The Band Perry which was loads of fun and very organic and natural. I liked Candice's version of this song much better, and it seemed a bit unnecessary having Amber sing a song that Candice had sung just last week. PSY - "Gentleman" C-/D+
This was sort of awful, but it got me dancing. I am STUNNED he didn't throw in a snippet of Gangnam Style in here, but PSY is probably trying to prove he is more than just a one hit wonder. Since this song is (somehow) on the charts, he is definitely on his way to proving that. Keith Urban - "Little Bit Of Everything" A+
I think this was the moment where I fell in love with Keith Urban. He is just the kind of guy you want to grab a beer with, under the summer sun, flip flops and a t-shirt. I know it's not just me! I realized with this performance that he is the antithesis of Mariah - all laid-back cool and low-key energy - where you know Mariah spent hours micromanaging every aspect of her performance (which ended up being sub-par compared to Keith's). I think we could all learn a lesson or two about life from Keith! Candice Glover & Jennifer Hudson - "Inseparable" A+
This was JAWDROPPING. Amazing. What can I even say? These two powerhouse vocalists brought the house down. We can end the show right there. Unbelievable! These two girls should record this song together. Angie Miller & Adam Lambert - "Titanium" / Angie Miller & Jessie J - "Domino" A+
You may argue that I am getting a bit liberal with the A+s here, but come on. I loved seeing Glambert back on the Idol stage. Angie began the song at the piano, duetting with Adam across the piano - it worked amazingly. Very emotional and dramatic, which I loved. The ache in Angie's voice was beautiful. I will buy this right now. Where is the link? Jessie J came out to sing her hit "Domino" with Angie and you could tell she was thrilled to sing with her favorite singer, Jessie J as well. A great performance and extremely fun! Keith Urban, Kree Harrison, & Randy Jackson - "Where The Blacktop Ends" A
Another awesome performance by Keith. This is the most relaxed and joyful I have ever seen Kree look on this stage. I think she should have performed with Keith every week! Clearly his chill attitude is rubbing off on her.
Aretha Franklin & Top 5 Girls - "Natural Woman"/"Never Loved A Man"/"Respect"/"Think" B/B-
Sort of an odd concept - Aretha is singing on a TV screen via satellite while the Top 5 girls sing backup vocals on the stage. It's kind of strange, but it (kind of) works. The choreography and red and black outfits are awesome though! Jennifer Lopez & Pitbull - "Live It Up" B
This is AT LEAST the 3rd song J. Lo & Pitbull have done together ("On The Floor", "Dance Again") and it's the worst of the three. That said, I LOVED the dancing and costumes (even those wild gladiator sandals J. Lo and the dancers had on). It was a pretty entertaining performance although I could have done without Pitbull entirely. Also what on earth does "let's hook tonight" mean? Hook up? Hookers? Whatever, #YOLO.
Kree Harrison & Candice Glover - "One Less Bell To Answer"/"A House Is Not A Home" A
Have we ever heard the two Idol finalists sing together before? If not, I don't know why not! They sound wonderful together, even though they are tackling two very old songs I wouldn't know if not for their inclusion on Glee. I only wish the producers could have given them a more fun song, but it doesn't matter at this point because they sound great. AND THE WINNER IS.....CANDICE GLOVER!
Candice Glover - "I Am Beautiful" A+
Of course, Candice was crying so hard her voice ended up a little muffled and strained. It was so emotional and wonderful - of course I cried, was there a doubt? It's been a long season and from her very audition, Candice is the one I was hoping would make it to the end. Her unjust cut in Vegas week last year was a CRIME against singing and I am glad that she came back this year and took the crown. I am so happy for Candice - she truly deserved this win and it's been a long road for her (auditioning 3 times).
Check out the Vegas week performance I'm talking about from Season 11 (with eventual Top 10 Season 11 contestants DeAndre Brackensick and Jessica Sanchez):
And on that amazing note, I sign off for American Idol Season 12. It's been real! Until Season 13...
The anticipation is high for this finale. And didn't it seem like a short show, only 1 hour, when we're used to the 2 hour episodes dragging out? It wouldn't hurt them to go back to this format every once in a while! Candice and Kree represent the best finale since 2009's Adam Lambert vs. Kris Allen Season 8 finale. Both girls have demonstrated unique song choices, beautiful voices, and some truly buzzworthy performances.
For tonight's episode, Round 1 is producer Simon Fuller's Choice, Round 2 is the Winner's Coronation Single, and Round 3 is a Reprise Performance from this season. Shaking things up a bit this year, as usually they end the night with the Coronation Single.
1. Kree - "Angel" (by Sarah McLachlan) A
I was astonished by how much I loved this performance, and how I never envisioned it as a country song before, but it all somehow worked perfectly. It was a very straightforward performance in the sense that she did not change the arrangement or delivery very much, but I loved the subtle country twist she gave the song - both in her tone of voice and the mournful country guitar sound. I cried during this performance because I really felt her delivery of the song and the true emotion embedded in every note of it. (Side note - finally they dressed Kree in something besides a Dress Barn leggings and maternity top combo and she looked gorgeous.)
2. Candice - "Chasing Pavements" (by Adele) A-
While Kree took a pop song and made it country, Candice took a pop song and made it jazzy. I love how she began this song in her deep, low register, really demonstrating the true range of her voice. She proved with this song that she does not need to do a million runs and belt out every song, but instead with her deliberate and delicate phrasing, really interpret a song. In other words, she doesn't fall back on vocal gymnastics to hide her lack of connection to the song or emotional interpretation.
3. Kree - "All Cried Out" B
In the context of the competition, I liked the song, but I did not love it - just not dynamic enough for me. I wish the song told more of a story in the traditional country style. I wonder how it will fare on the country charts. In parts of the song, it sounded like she was straining a bit. Although I've been waiting all season to purchase the winner's single, I'm not sure this is what I was looking for.
4. Candice - "I Am Beautiful" B
Unfortunately, this song didn't live up to what I was hoping for either. OF COURSE the Idol producers would saddle these two extremely talented contestants with sub-par, mediocre songs. I would just expect nothing less at this point. I gave both of these songs the benefit of the doubt, but if they're going to be this sub-par, I wish they would stop trying to make the songs "current" and failing and just go back to the "This Is My Now" / "Do I Make You Proud" style of over-blown, melodramatic, cheesefests. At least those are good in their own right! Anyway, back to Candice's performance. It also sounded like Candice was straining a bit at parts of the performance but I will say she seemed more emotionally connected to the song than Kree had.
5. Kree - "Up To The Mountain" A+
After a very sleepy Round 2, if you did not wake up for Round 3 of this competition, as Keith would say - call your doctor, because you don't have a pulse. This is the sort of performance that gets you up off your couch, that you feel in every beat of your heart, and the core of your being. It is obvious how very connected Kree is to this song and it was reflected in her spirited and moving performance. I literally did not want this performance to end and I think that's the highest praise I can possibly give!
6. Candice - "I Who Have Nothing" A+
This was LITERALLY MINDBLOWING. When she started the song acapella and stayed there for more than just two lines, I think I got up off the couch. SHE LITERALLY BROUGHT THE HOUSE DOWN. This song was so VISCERAL, so INTENSELY powerful. That voice is once in a lifetime and even more so, she knows how to make the listener feel what she is feeling. Maybe not even relate it to their own personal life, but she offers a glimpse into her own emotions and her own story. It is rare to find a singer than can do that so fully, especially on this show. HOW she was cut last year in Vegas Week is a greater mystery!
In closing, I think it's been a great season with a few amazing contestants (Kree, Candice, Angie) who shined so brightly that they made up for all the dim stars. It's going to be a tough race and it is so obvious Candice has been my favorite all season, but if Kree runs off with the sash and crown, I won't be (too) disappointed.
Until tomorrow, Idol lovers - it's been a while since I've written a recap of the finale and I think it's time I revisit that!
Top 3 - Jimmy's Choice, Judges' Choice, & Producers' Choice - May 8, 2013
1. Kree Harrison - "Perfect" B
The opening to this song was really gorgeous and interesting to listen to as you could really hear the country tone in Kree's song. And it's not something you'd expect to hear in a rendition of this hit song by Pink. Unfortunately Kree stumbled a bit on the chorus, where the verses were much stronger. I can imagine this was a song choice she never would have chosen on her own (and she admitted as much in the post-performance interview with Ryan), but she did a decent job with it.
2. Candice Glover - "One" A/A-
Candice's tone is so rich and lush; I absolutely love listening to her sing so I can hear what specific and intentional choices she takes with the song. She makes each song her own through her emotional interpretation of the lyrics and melody. Candice really got to soar with this song choice - Jimmy really picked a great one for her. She incorporated the emotion and power in these song lyrics and really took off.
3. Angie Miller - "Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word" B/B-
This performance from start to finish was sleepy for me after the electrifying performance by Candice. While her voice sounded beautiful and pure, I didn't really like the song or her delivery of it. Angie's tone slipped into being unpleasant when she hit some of the higher notes.
4. Candice - "Next To Me" B
While "Next To Me" by Emile Sande is one of my favorite new songs on the radio right now, this song choice failed to produce a "wow" moment for Candice. While of course she sang it magnificently, it paled in comparison to the other Round 2 song choices. Keith was right that she delivered the first few lines in a conversational tone, really drawing in the listener. But I was lost a bit at the "clapping" part of the song - she really picked it up again after that inane clapping stopped!
5. Angie - "Try" A
I love this song and I LOVE that Angie finally let go with the song, embraced her rocker side, stopped making eyes at the camera, and really had fun with the performance. Finally she brought to life a "mid-uptempo" song and sold it believably. It was a fun and very sexy performance where she almost felt like the lead singer in the band. I absolutely loved this and I can't wait to post the YouTube video once the American Idol Official Channel puts it up.
6. Kree - "Here Comes Goodbye" A+
I am not ashamed to admit I cried for a solid 15 minutes watching Kree's hometown visit video as well as her beautiful performance of this Rascal Flatts song. This is so heartfelt, emotional, moving, and absolutely gorgeously sung. She really told a story with her voice, note choices, and delivery and it was amazing.
Try not to cry while watching this:
And Kree's performance:
7. Angie - "Maybe" B/B-
This was not the Idol Moment (TM) she needed for her last performance on the Idol Stage before the 2013 Finale. It distracted me that she didn't seem to be playing the piano at all for at least the first half of the song. I thought the song was sort of cloying in a way (or maybe it was Angie's delivery which seemed a bit strained at parts). Solid but not great.
8. Kree - "Better Dig Two" B+
At first I loved this song choice for Kree. I'd never heard the song before and it was catchy and uptempo. But upon further reflection, I think it soldified my thoughts that the Idol Producers want Kree to be a distinct 3rd place finisher. She is not as dynamic as Candice and not as "marketable" (whatever that means) as Angie. Idol voters don't really like things that have an edgy lyrical content like this - and sometimes they vote based on last impressions. I think Kree would have been much better off with her last impression being "Here Comes Goodbye" which was an absolutely amazing performance.
9. Candice - "Somewhere" A+
I love how she started in a subtle but gorgeous way with the song and as the emotion built, her voice built and grew as well. This was truly an Idol Moment (and the only true one of the Final 3 performances). Candice earned her place in the finale with this song (as if she hadn't all season - duh!) Unbelievable. Candice is a master class in singing perfection.
Angie starts off the show with a beautiful and understated cover of the hit Rihanna song. It is interesting how bare-bones this song is when you strip it down. The limitation of the lyrics becomes very apparent. Angie's voice was a bit shaky in parts, but I liked her version of this song. A common theme throughout the night was the strange arrangements given to some of these songs. I would have preferred if the band had not come in on this song, and just allowed Angie's voice and her piano playing to carry the song (or not - as the case may be).
2. Amber Holcomb - "Just Give Me A Reason" B-/C+
One of the night's many breakup ballads and this one fell a bit flat in comparison. It was a bit startling to see in her pre-performance package how disconnected she was to the lyrics of her second song. And on second listen, I wonder if it affected her performance here as well. This is a devastating breakup ballad and her enunciation on some of the words was hard to make out. She also smiled at some inopportune parts of the performance. Pink's voice demonstrates all the ache and devastation of the words and Amber just could not match that. 3. Candice Glover - "When I Was Your Man" A++
It only took me until the first chorus to begin crying. Unlike Amber, I truly BELIEVE every word, every heartbreak in Candice's voice. She inhabits the lyrics in a way few singers truly do. Can I admit I have never heard the original Bruno Mars song?? Maybe that aided in my enjoyment of Candice's performance. Not only was it a powerhouse, perfect vocal, Candice succeeded in moving the audience in a way that arguably none of her fellow contestants did. This was an absolutely stunning performance and by far and away, the best of the night. I agreed with Nicki's critique that this sounded like it could actually be Candice's song and not a cover version.
4. Kree Harrison - "See You Again" A
I wish the band had not come in on this Carrie Underwood cover, and just kept the arrangement as Kree and the Hot American Idol Guitar Player (TM). The arrangements have been so hokey and uninspired, and this was no exception. What really shined in this song was Kree's passion and emotion. I believed every note, I believed every word. I saw the pain in her eyes and felt it too. There are many great singers, but not as many great storytellers with beautiful voices - and in this performance, that is what Kree was.
5. Angie Miller - "Someone To Watch Over Me" B
I think I figured it out about Angie - when she is not sitting behind the piano, she comes off as though she is starring in her very own Broadway musical. And somehow, it (mostly) works for her. Her intonation, phrasing, the way she builds from a soft whisper to belting - it's all extremely Broadway. While I am not sure she fits into the current pop landscape, I don't doubt that she'll have a very successful stage career. 6. Amber Holcomb - "My Funny Valentine" B-
I didn't like Amber's performance this time around as much as I did the first time she performed it back on the Top 20 girls round. She stood out then among more mediocre talents. But with the high level of talent amongst these 4 girls, this didn't quite compare to me. There were a few parts where she went high pitched and it went a bit unpleasant. I wished more than anything she would choose a song where she moved from behind the mike. I wonder if that it's she can't move in the heels and just chooses to stay put. Whatever the reason, I always find her performances a little sleepier than the rest as she just is not a dynamic performer.
I've embedded her original performance below:
7. Candice Glover - "You've Changed" A
Like I mentioned before, Candice is the sort of storyteller who draws you in immediately with her voice and inflections. I loved the jazzy turns and runs she did on this song - they fit in so well with the song's style and the overall vibe. The staging and atmosphere was so perfect as well. She is captivating with each performance. Although I didn't love "You've Changed" as much as "When I Was Your Man", both performances were amazing and complimented each other in an interesting way.
8. Kree Harrison - "Stormy Weather" B+
Her voice sounded great but overall something was missing from this performance for me. It was a bit sleepy. To be honest, it's hard for me to recap this song because it didn't leave much of an impression on me - and it was the last performance of the night!
In closing, I will never understand why Harry Connick Jr. has not been on EVERY episode this season. Or is not seated behind the judges table. He is amazing and made this episode for me!
Best of the night: Candice - "When I Was Your Man" Worst of the night: Amber - "Just Give Me A Reason"
Top 4 - April 24, 2013 - Contestant's Choice &1 Hit Wonders 1. Amber Holcomb - "The Power Of Love" A
Amber's performance of this song, originally by Laura Branigan and most famously covered by Celine Dion, was unbelievably gorgeous. I could only notice one "off" note. The rest of it was right on point. I could hear a youthfulness in her voice that I've never really heard in anyone's rendition of this song before (not even Hollie Cavanagah's from last season).
Now, examining this performance in the context of the competition, it came off EXTREMELY dated. Celine's version came out in 1993 and that is EXACTLY when this performance - both visually and auditory - could have been taped. It could have been a performance at the 1993 Grammy Awards. Now, I'm not complaining, because I love the 80's and 90's when it comes to fashion, technology, music, movies, TV, etc. BUT the judges spent literally the majority of the show tonight - even after OTHER contestants' performances - praising Amber and saying how "current" this performance was. Don't get me wrong, it was a great performance, but NOTHING current about it.
2. Candice Glover - "Find Your Love" A+
I loved the deep parts of her voice, I loved how she infused this whole song with a jazzy, slow-burn vocal. It is an absolute TRAVESTY how Candice did not get the credit she deserved for this original, exciting, unexpected performance from the judges. She took a hip-hop song with a rap vocal and turned it into a completely different, unique song with both jazz and R&B elements. It was fascinating and fabulous. I won't even waste space on how off-base and insane the judges were with their critique on this performance. I like it even better the second time I listened to it than the first!
For those not familiar with the original version by Drake, I've embededed it:
And Candice's version:
3. Kree Harrison - "Hurts So Bad" A-
I heard some Carrie Underwood in her voice, for the first time in this competition. It's not a bad comparison to make, for sure! Kree really had a lot of grit and a gravelly tone in her voice during this song, which made it a bit different from some of her previous performances. It was a great choice for Kree, who gravitates towards country songs with a blues base.
4. Angie Miller - "Who You Are" B
I can't lie, this song has been done to death on Idol this season and I find it to be a very cloying, "dare to be different", artificial song without much that's genuine or moving to it. I mean, with lyrics like, "it's OK not to be OK"....come on. Ugh. I feel like I've heard it way too many times on Idol, and the song's melody forces Angie into a place where to me she sounds a bit unpleasant and sharp. Angie started the song very pretty but she lost me a bit along the way as the song irritated me more and more. I do love her performances at the piano where she can really shine. DUET #1 - Kree & Amber - "Rumour Has It" B-/C+
There was just something off about this whole performance from start to finish. The chemistry between the two singers wasn't there, as Nicki correctly pointed out. I loved the staging with the giant drums and film strip background. The vocals weren't as up to par as they could have been. It's not something I'd listen to ever again.
DUET #2 - Angie & Candice - "Stay" A
This was infinitely better than the previous duet. It must be pointed out that these two ladies had the benefit of hearing the critique Nicki Minaj gave the previous duet and perhaps adjusting their performance slightly based on it. But maybe not. This was all around a better song choice, better vocals, and a more interesting performance visually and vocally.
5. Amber Holcomb - "MacArthur Park" C-
Let's point out a few things about this song. First, it was already performed by Carrie Underwood on this show, so it's a bit of a dangerous tread. Second, it ACTUALLY contains the following lyrics:
Someone left the cake out in the rain /I don't think that I can take it/ Cause it took so long to bake it
/ And I'll never have that recipe again
I am honestly not sure what to make of it. Also the lyrics mention "drinking wine while it is warm", which is just a disgusting idea in general. This song was also released in 1968, making it even more strange that the judges would give Amber constant critiques of being "the whole package", "so 2013", "the next Rihanna", etc. when she chose a 1993 Celine Dion power ballad and this sap fest from 1968. Her vocal was wobbly from the start on this song and the disco part was atrocious. How is she current when she can't even move around on an uptempo? It's basically a requirement for pop stars to dance and perform these days. Gone are the days when people can stand still at a mic stand and perform - although you'd never know it from watching American Idol this season!
6. Candice Glover - "Emotions" A-/B+
I've never liked this song much - the Destiny's Child version OR Bee Gees version - I have to be honest, but Candice breathed new life into it for me. I loved the part where the music dropped for a second and her vocal was allowed to take center stage. I would have to admit that it's a bit of a boring song choice and not particularly memorable. Probably my least favorite of Candice's performances, but she is such an unbelievable singer that she literally probably could sing the hell out of any song.
7. Kree - "A Whiter Shade Of Pale" A-
I think right off the bat I had to give Kree some bonus points for song choice. This song is absolutely unbelievable and one that I'll always remember from growing up on the music of Motown, the 50's, and 60's. Her voice sounded sweet and ethereal in the beginning verse - I think I would have loved to hear more angst in it right from the start. I probably would have given Kree a B+ otherwise, but this song really grabbed me. I wished she had done a bit more with it however.
8. Angie - "Cry Me A River" A+
SADLY, Angie did not perform the Justin Timberlake song, but a true one hit wonder song that I had never heard. This performance was VERY Broadway - in the delivery and the staging. I almost feel like this could have been a number from CATS. That is not exactly a compliment or an insult. Angie's voice was absolutely beautiful and I loved that she put some attitude in her vocal without losing that beauty. Listening to this performance made me wonder if she will go on to star on Broadway - I wouldn't doubt it!
Best of the night: Candice - "Find Your Love" and Angie - "Cry Me A River" Worst of the night: Amber - "MacArthur Park"